Although He Self Identifies As Gay, Elián Continues To Surprise Himself And Me In Terms Of The Direct Prostate Stimulation Since It's Not Something That He Practices Or Participates In In His Private Sex Life.

10 min

Straight Guy Can't Get Enough Of My Fingers Pro

10 min

I Knew When Shayne Contacted Me On My Favorite

6 min

Leeroy's Body Showed The Direct Prostate Stimul

9 min

Drew Pulled His Heels Back & The Toy Slid Right

8 min

MandingoMar Sexperiences His First Direct Prost

7 min

A Perfect Ten INCHES! Dear Gawd In All Of My T

5 min

Pushing 50 Oliver Has Just Discovered The Joys

3 min

So Admittedly Soren Pretty Much Trips My Trig

3 min

He's BAAAAaaaack! For The First Time Since Dece

4 min

To Celebrate ClubAmateurUSA's 750th Exclusive

4 min

Over The Past Few Months There Have Been Sever

6 min

Straight Dude Braydyn Relaxed & The Toy Slid Ri

6 min

Quinlan's Eyes Roll Back As Casey's Finger Find

4 min

Tariq's Thick Cock Pulsed Throughout The Anal P

4 min

CAUSA Newbie Quinlynn Sooooo Wasn't Mentally Pr

4 min

ClubAmateurUSA's Annual "Black Friday Special!"

5 min

His Eyes Rolled Back As My Tongue Worked It's M

8 min

CAUSA Classic CUMpilation Circle Jerk Guys | Ni

7 min

Klaus Is CAUSA's First Fair Skinned Blue Eyed

36 sec

More Fingers Please

6 min

Husband Becomes The Meat In The Sandwich

6 min

My Tongue Slid Into His Ass & Corey Was At Full

17 min

Bryce FUCKS Adrian In The Ass Before POUNDING M

10 min

I Had His Prostate A Swellin' His Precum A Dri

6 min

Riyaz's Accidental Ejaculation Is Triggered By

2 min

Erick Diaz E Victor Ferraz "Marreta"

10 min

CAUSA 553 Kristoff Part 1

6 min

Demarcus' Eyes Roll Back As I Massage His Prostate

6 min

This Straight Guy Can't Get Enough Of My Finger

7 min

CAUSA 555 CUMpilation Hot Chocolate Part 2

5 min

Straight Noob Discovers The Male G Spot — His P

10 min

Cameron Almost Came Off The Table As My Finger

6 min

Going All The Way Back To October 2003 And The

6 min

Juicy Lucas Prostate Squeeze

12 min

Straight Hot BBC 1st Bi Experience Wt Sexy Coup

4 min

Butch Arab Breeds French Slut

2 min

Daddy Chris Barebacking Gay Guys

6 min

Extreme Deepthroat With My Straight Friend In A

5 min

Encontrei Meu Vizinho Mega Dotado No Elevador M

17 min

Big Dick Delivery Guy Gets Lucky And Fucks BOTH